Negs about xplane 10 i have to download freeware airport scenery. Welcome to this video where i compare some of the features of fsx and xplane. X plane simulates aerodynamics using a model simulation, that means the actual shape of the plane defines how it flies, how it be. Its hard to compete with the sheer amount of addons available for p3d vs xplane. Fsx, prepar3d, xplane who won the battle for flightsim supremacy last year. Yes its the granddaddy, yes its got more devotees than a devo tshirt kiosk. I have used p3d since the very first beta came out all the way till now v3. So ive been off of flightsim for close to 10 years now and keen to get back into it however im at a bit of a crossroads. The xplane hd scenery is an improved version of the base scenery. If you appreciated this content, please consider a donation. Fsx was never made for a 64bit computer since when it was release date did not warrant it.
However, by now i only use ixeg in x plane and would like to buy some new aircrafts. Obviously im using addons with fsx to enhance the scenery and environment but it still quite amusing that p3d and xplane 10 are not miles ahead. The 2 high end sims right now are x plane 11 and prepar3d v4. Based on popular request and based on many of the videos i have seen of prepar3d v4 vs xplane 11, i decided to create this comparison video. I started using x plane about 3 months ago, when ixeg 737 came out and i absolutely love it. What are the main differences between fsx and xplane. Please let me know your thoughts on the video dropping a comment below. I cant decide between p3d and xplane 11 the prepar3d. Both the new entirely remodeled and enhanced vc and the 2d panel are now equipped with all authentic german gauges. Flight dynamics feel so much better than fsxp3d too. Guys, i am not here to start a flame war between the two products, but i do hope to start a pro vs cons list thats unbiased as possible in the best interest of the community. Most existing fsx and esp addons work with prepar3d. Xplane simulates aerodynamics using a model simulation, that means the actual shape of the plane defines how it flies, how it be.
Fsw vs xplane 11 flight sim world general discussions. Fsx set my airport to kiag niagara falls, take off in my pitts and head to the falls and perform aerobatic ducks and dives beneath the bridge just before the falls. X plane s flight dynamics just feel better to me for small, light aircraft, and i prefer x plane s rendition of scenery up close. The video is quite detailed and therefore quite long, but it is worth watching for a full comparison. The package includes a wheeled and a float version of the aircraft. The fsx landing was terrible, and i blame it entirely on the. What is perhaps most interesting, to both experienced users and beginners alike, is just how different these two flight sim packages actually are. In the article, we may use the abbreviated forms of each sim so for clarity, fsx means microsoft flight simulator x, p3d means prepar3d and xp11 means x plane 11.
Prepar3d general aviation 78 prepar3d helicopters 8 prepar3d jetliners 48 prepar3d modern military 32 prepar3d other aircraft 3 prepar3d prop airliners 6 prepar3d turboprops 19 prepar3d warbirds 30 a1r design cp80 racer for fsxp3d. X plane 11 has better graphics, some changes in physics and has alot of other advantages compared to x plane 10. Question about different flight simsfsx vs prepar3d vs. At high altitudes, scenery and flight dynamics really doesnt matter much, and p3d offers nicer weather. Need an upgrade to hardware to be able to run xp11, but being semiretired and limited budget, not going to happen near term so i am running fsx steam for now. Jan 06, 2016 while the planes fly more realistically as a whole, some of the good addon planes for fsx p3d fly very realistically as well, and the panels are usually much more realistic and more systems are simulated vs. Then watch the tourist boats cruise at the foot of the falls. How is the performance of x plane 10 64bit with respect to fsx 32bit simulator. The ultimate weather engine for fsx, prepar3d v1v3 and xplane 10 giving you the best real weather experience in your simulator. Unless you have upgraded your computer equipment, if you couldnt run xplane 10, you wont be able to run xplane 11. Xplane 10, released in march 2012, retains its macintosh rootsit is available for mac osx as well as windows and linux. Unless you have upgraded your computer equipment, if you couldnt run x plane 10, you wont be able to run x plane 11.
So i have fsx and xplane 10 and have just got p3d v3, i thought both x plane 10 and p3d v3 would be visually streets ahead of fsx but i have to say that the now 10 years old fsx is still a match for them imo. Nov 22, 2016 guys, i am not here to start a flame war between the two products, but i do hope to start a pro vs cons list thats unbiased as possible in the best interest of the community. Yes, even though i cant really go back to fsx, there are still two things that get me about xplanedont get me wrong, i love xp1011 and fly it as my main commercialga sim, lack of a proper ai traffic systemi know there is xlife, but it doesnt support enough airports and fspassengersair hauler 2 not being available for it. It consists of a more detailed ground triangle mesh and more accurate landclass data representation. It includes improved forests, accurate rivers, lakes, coastline, road and railroad networks based on updated osm data. Fsx vs x plane 10 comparison cessna 172 aircraft, scenery and handling. In the article, we may use the abbreviated forms of each sim so for clarity, fsx means microsoft flight simulator x, p3d means prepar3d and xp11 means xplane 11. This may have been discussed a lot so i apologize if this may make your eyes roll but here is what i am taking from doing a little for homework. Jun 30, 2014 welcome to this video where i compare some of the features of fsx and x plane.
Even as a newcomer to development, this will be a great place to start and learn the environment and contribute to the success of the product and the community. They both are excellent simulators, which is why im having such trouble deciding which to choose. Jun 09, 2017 so, when you want to compare fsx fsw prepar3d to x plane 10 11 then you better include the x plane freeware scene to present a more balanced assessment. Yes, even though i cant really go back to fsx, there are still two things that get me about x plane dont get me wrong, i love xp1011 and fly it as my main commercialga sim, lack of a proper ai traffic systemi know there is x life, but it doesnt support enough airports and fspassengersair hauler 2 not being available for it. Dec 23, 2014 will divide this answer in topics, from the most important to me to the least important. I already own fsxfswprepar3d and a ton of expensive payware to go with them. But if you want to totally nerd out and want to feel like youre flying a real airliner with all of the. Flight simulator x steam edition vs xplane 11 public beta 2. Hello guys, i am happy flightsimmer, who use p3d and xplane regularly both sims have pros and cons, we all know that. As a user of xplane and p3d got to say i am really starting to be won over by xplane. Fsx vs xplane 10 comparison cessna 172 aircraft, scenery. You get two copies of prepar3d to do this development with.
If you dont really care and just want to mess around, i suppose either one might hold your interest. Sim wise the flight feel for p3d is more arcade but you do have some better flight models that you can buy and many of choices. Previously i compared these sims using the boeing 737, now we take a look at xplane vs. While the planes fly more realistically as a whole, some of the good addon planes for fsxp3d fly very realistically as well, and the panels are usually much more realistic and more systems are simulated vs. Apart from the airport and the weather from xenviro everything else is either default or freeware. Microsoft flight simulator x wservice pack 2 required or flight simulator x steam edition or lockheed martins prepar3d v3 or v4 compatible with acceleration pack and dx10. Xplane or prepar3d flight simulator flightsim planet.
Xplane 10 global is the most recent version of the venerable xplane franchise. X plane or back to fsx firstly, if you click forum near the top of this page and scroll down through the forums list and glance at the viewing readouts, youll see that far more people are always viewing the fsx forum than all the others combined, which. Fsx microsoft flight simulator x fs9 microsoft flight simulator also known as. X plane11 zibo mod is hands down the most accurate 737800 you can get and its free and worked on almost daily with many updates weekly.
Dec 09, 2016 flight simulator x steam edition vs x plane 11 public beta 2. So, when you want to compare fsxfsw prepar3d to x plane 10 11 then you better include the x plane freeware scene to present a more balanced assessment. There is no reason not to jump aboard now estimates are x plane 11 is still 1 to 2 years away rumour mill. Well fsx steam edition is a very less advanced as compared to prepar 3d or xp lane 10 and we talk about x plane and p3d then yeah both are best in their own sense as the level of work and detailing done is tremendous. Fsx primary sim, many glorious addons i cant part with still, precious rxp gauges etc, not as flashy. It looks better out of the box and can take advantage of more of your systems hardware. Fsx mods are better, that is true but there are really good addons for. How is the performance of xplane 10 64bit with respect to fsx 32bit simulator. This is an fsx panel update for the focke wulf fw 58, previously designed for fsx by a. Some airliner aircraft comparison xplane vs p3d the x.
I already own fsx fsw prepar3d and a ton of expensive payware to go with them. Apr 11, 2019 if youre interested in reading about our comparison of fsx vs xplane 11, check out our article here. There is no reason not to jump aboard now estimates are xplane 11 is still 1 to 2 years away rumour mill. Ive never owned xplane before xplane 11, but ive got to say, the quality of the graphics is outstanding. May 26, 2018 its hard to compete with the sheer amount of addons available for p3d vs x plane. I typically fly ga in x plane, and bigger things in p3d. First i had to download two different applications. Heres a short video of a flight using the default 172, out of toronto. Fsx is a dead end software, it will not be improved or further developed by microsoft simply.
Jun 21, 2018 previously i compared these sims using the boeing 737, now we take a look at xplane vs. Fsx mods are better, that is true but there are really good addons for x plane 11, too, like f. Jul 17, 2019 in the article, we may use the abbreviated forms of each sim so for clarity, fsx means microsoft flight simulator x, p3d means prepar3d and xp11 means x plane 11. Unfortunately, microsoft has taken an unexpected turn and made their simulator into a realistic game so i dont foresee them make future improvements. The flight modeling is also reputed to be well beyond that of p3d. What you see in that video, is not planned for the current live cycle of xplane 10, but is planned for the next release 11, and you will need to pay again for it. Jul 18, 2016 hello guys, i am happy flightsimmer, who use p3d and x plane regularly both sims have pros and cons, we all know that. Fsx vs p3d v3 vs xplane 10 microsoft flight simulator x. The 2 high end sims right now are xplane 11 and prepar3d v4. Games downloads prepar3d by lockheed martin corporation. So, when you want to compare fsxfswprepar3d to xplane 1011 then you better include the xplane freeware scene to present a more balanced assessment. Prepar3d vs aces vs xplane vs ms flight prepar3d forums. Features include real upper and lower air winds, cloud types, clear air turbulence, icing, historic. This is a graphics intensive simulation and a powerful pc is required.
Flight dynamics are far less realistic, and quality of graphics is far worse than xplane 11, even with a plethora of add one. Fsx vs xplane pc flight simulation downloads and more. After reading a lot of articles and what not im torn as to what simulator to use whether its fsx vs x plane vs prepar3d correct me if im wrong but ive read that p3d is an addon like thingy for fsx. I typically fly ga in xplane, and bigger things in p3d. After reading a lot of articles and what not im torn as to what simulator to use whether its fsx vs xplane vs prepar3d correct me if im wrong but. I have to say, though, that the quality of the aircraft is the standard.
The aircraft that come with this package look excellent. Do a comparison between the new p3d v4 which is the latest successor of the fsx series and x plane 11. I havent played either sim ive only seen videos or read articles. I started using xplane about 3 months ago, when ixeg 737 came out and i absolutely love it. As of right now, im enjoying a flight in the qualitywings 787, but later on i may do a justflight c152 flight in xplane 11, the ortho4xp really makes xplane a wonderful ga simulator. The original xplane was released in 1993 for the macintosh. Will divide this answer in topics, from the most important to me to the least important. Apr 12, 2016 so i have fsx and xplane 10 and have just got p3d v3, i thought both x plane 10 and p3d v3 would be visually streets ahead of fsx but i have to say that the now 10 years old fsx is still a match for them imo. As a user of x plane and p3d got to say i am really starting to be won over by x plane. With the latest versions of xp 10 and foreflight, just click on the correct button in the xplane options menu, then enable the xplane device in the foreflight options menu. As of right now, im enjoying a flight in the qualitywings 787, but later on i may do a justflight c152 flight in x plane 11, the ortho4xp really makes x plane a wonderful ga simulator. With that in mind, lets have a look at the 2014 avsim demographic survey. X plane or back to fsx firstly, if you click forum near the top of this page and scroll down through the forums list and glance at the viewing readouts, youll see that far more people are always viewing the fsx forum than all the others combined, which is a good indication of how popular fsx is. I already own fsxfsw prepar3d and a ton of expensive payware to go with them.
1269 1120 1516 952 543 252 842 488 762 1595 1382 250 521 1375 1358 61 1321 1647 597 345 943 582 903 780 1482 1544 1516 1571 113 1423 281 924 1206 848 349 863 1310 426 390 650 778 375